ALIENABILITY OF BENEFICIARY’S INTEREST:
- Must manifest intent to create inalienability
- Any interest in trust is assignable (with exceptions)
- Trustee can create inalienable trust = “spendthrift trust” – most states permit
- Can be either mandatory, support or discretionary type trust
- Regulated by state statute – Prop 112.035
- Two theories:
• American – property rights are absolute
- Not too practical because credit checks don’t show up inter vivos trust and tort claims are different – no decision to make on part of tort recipient
• England – should have to pay bills (protecting creditors)
- Sligh
• Creates exception to inalienability of spendthrift trusts for tort claimaints
• Ascher REALLY agrees
• Restatement 2nd is neutral on this issue
- Child support is another exception
• This is in the 2nd Restatement
• Also alimony but less widely accepted than child support
- Cutting edge law
• Fam 14.05c:
- Mandatory payment – child support forced
- Discretionary trust – child support from INCOME only
- Schreiber – lawyers’ fees forceable?
• Creates exception in PA
• See 2nd Restatement 157c,
• Lawyers must preserve or benefit the beneficiary’s interests
- Does not have to be financial benefit
• Restatement 2nd 157a, b, also allow creditors to get to spendthrift trust for necessities (rent, food, etc.)
• Rationale in Schreiber:
- Piercing the trust for benefit is unjust enrichment theory and no benefit creates no unjust enrichment
• Texas case law (Smith) indicates exception
- Governmental Claims
• Restatement 2nd 157d – but preemption covers
• So Restatement 3rd omits (also not a matter of trust law – up to the Feds and the states)
- Voluntary/Involuntary Alienation
• Including one implies including the other
- Actual distributions become ineffective upon distribution
- Practical effect of invalid assignment
• If give interest, once given, assignee can keep it
• Trustee treats as revocable order to pay assignee
We have located some similar legal questions and legal question categories. Check out these challenging questions that askquestions about Interests and are similar to What do you mean by ALIENABILITY OF BENEFICIARY’S INTEREST?. Also, we have included a list of some of our more popular legal question categories. These categories are based on what everyone is asking and answering.
What's Your Answer to "What do you mean by ALIENABILITY OF BENEFICIARY’S INTEREST?"