Facts: The evidence presented does not show if one can walk from one-half of the
property to the other. The pictures indicate that one can walk through or across it and
that such a hollow is not unusual for the Ozarks. There is an indication that a road might
be necessary for cattle to cross the hollow, but no evidence regarding what would be
necessary to construct a path or road sufficient only for cattle, or what it would cost.
Issue: Is P entitled under – 228. 340 to a roadway of necessity because a portion of their
property does not have a public road “through or alongside” it; and P’s do not have, and
cannot reasonable provide for, vehicular access to that portion of their property from a
portion with access to a public road?
Holding: Reversed. P has one tract of land with a public road alongside the tract and this
P is not entitled to relief.
– The statute should be strictly construed. A literal application would deny P’s
claim as a “public road passes thru or alongside their land”. The only time this
statute has granted a roadway when a portion of the property has a road along side
it was in Wiese where P lived on a farm with land that was completely separated
by a river and the other side was completely useless. The court determined that
the river made the two pieces of land as “separate tracts” and affirmed the
granting of a private road of necessity.
– This case is different from Wiese because there the river made the land into two
separate tracts and here P’s property is still one tract. To allow a private roadway
would be to change the statutory language. The court would be allowing a private
road because a vehicle cannot travel from one portion of the same tract to a public
– The statute authorizes the establishment of a private road only for the purpose of
providing egress and ingress to land not bordering upon a public road and there is
no other interpretation.
We have located some similar legal questions and legal question categories. Check out these challenging questions that askquestions about Property Law Cases and are similar to What were the facts and holdings in the case Hollers v. Church of God of Apostolic Faith, Inc.?. Also, we have included a list of some of our more popular legal question categories. These categories are based on what everyone is asking and answering.