Maryland v. Craig – one-way closed circuit T.V. allowed with a court finding that the child would suffer distress
held face-to-face not an absolute right (ex. some hearsay) (though still a strong preference, must give way to considerations of public policy and necessities of the case)
judge makes finding maybe using social worker opinion
face-to-face can be overcome by certain circumstances
court has substantial interest in protecting child abuse victims
this way D can see child testifying, but child never has to see D
dissent: Constitution says face to face, means in presence of D
case a catalyst for states to change laws
note: D can still call child as a witness, though … at that point child not have same protection
D definitely gets to see the witness
Hearsay Ok …
if falls under traditional hearsay exception, or
if there is a indicia of reliability
Preliminary Hearings
have to have counsel
issue of probable cause
D counsel may not want to point out holes in witness testimony bc it alerts the P
Danger witnesses may not be around at time of trial and P will offer as a hearsay statement
P will argue D had opportunity to fully question at preliminary hearing
A traditional hearsay exception from former proceeding where opportunity to c-x
If D does not show up or leaves in the middle …
never shows up, difficult situation (if D alerted, case law says can start but most jurisdictions decline to proceed)
leaves in middle can proceed
Presence of D in Courtroom
NO absolute right for D to be there if so disrupted should be excluded
Goal is to get D to behave (first warn, then threat contempt…)
If kicked out, allow back in if promise to be good
If D is own attorney, this is why you need stand-in counsel
We have located some similar legal questions and legal question categories. Check out these challenging questions that askquestions about Criminal Law Cases and are similar to What was the holding in the case Maryland v. Craig ?. Also, we have included a list of some of our more popular legal question categories. These categories are based on what everyone is asking and answering.
What's Your Answer to "What was the holding in the case Maryland v. Craig ?"